What they say ~ Creates smooth lines that are defined and precise. Smudge-proof, budge-proof and water-resistant coverage for all day wear to combat against, sweat, tears and rain!
What I say ~ This is a really good product and I like the cream liner, I have to use it with a special brush which needs washing each time after use which is a bit of a faff. It is pretty much budge proof as well which is good. I have tried using as a eyeshadow base which didn't work really as it creased up quickly although that may have been because I applied it too thick. This shade is in midnight which is a navy colour, it applies nice enough and the only issue I have is this particular colour needs two layers to achieve a deep shade where as the black one doesn't. This is a matte eyeliner.
Would I buy it again ~ Not sure, I am much more a black eyeliner kind of a person. If I did want a navy one though I might do.