This is a battle of the beige polishes
Not my favorite battle but I do use a lot of them for nail art bases. Doubt I would wear any of these other than the chocolate alone. Round one, and getting them down to three wasn't too difficult. I ended up with Rose Gold which is amazing for stamping for a bargain price of £2 delivered. ELF n*de is nice for a french or for some nail art.
The winner is ELF's Smokey Brown, I have used up two of these and have this one plus a back up. It just works really well with my skin tone as a base for something more snazzy. Something I cannot be without.